Tools of the Mind was set to bring another training to our campus in April, but after discussion of keeping the curriculum for the coming year, our leadership felt it was best to select another option.
The news came when I was still out on Spring Break and I was really disappointed in this decision. In reflection, I initially wasn’t sure how much I liked the curriculum – it is very scripted and leaves little room for creativity. However, after a year of implementing it and seeing the growth in my students, I am a huge supporter and had I planned to stay at my school a third year, would have fought hard to keep Tools.
Words do little to explain the pros and cons – but I cannot imagine another curriculum providing the same level of self-regulation that TOTM has. Sure, it was frustrating in the first year, but the development of my students who have had Tools for two years is phenomenal. So much of what it offered makes incredible sense – rolling out a base layer and building. I am only halfway through assessing year-long vocabulary growth, but I have seen most students grow an average of 1.5-2 years! THIS IS HUGE!!!!!
If we did not have dramatic play centers, I don’t think I would have been able to have such deep discussions and on-the-spot lessons about veterinarians, cashier’s, how a business functions and emergency rooms. With that being said, I was constantly begging for Tools kindergarden work, for my students who were excelling and needed more challenge. This has been the perfect curriculum for ELL’s and special needs students though, as it caters to self-regulation and language development.
So, I am torn. I was also hoping to become certified in Tools, so that if I did end up staying in the classroom to continue my work, I could continue utilizing the curriculum wherever I taught. Personally (welcome to my soapbox!), I do not believe that two years is a long enough period to understand the peaks and pitfalls of any curriculum, or to see long-term development. At the same time, education is not an experiment, but something which can absolutely change someone’s entire life.
After the announcement, my co-teacher and I opted to keep the Tools activities we love, and increase the rigor of other areas of our day. Instead of play plans, we utilized journals to begin moving towards kindergarten work. This was in an effort to move our students out of the “lines” phase (voice to line match to understand word development) and onto lined paper to be their own authors. We are so excited at the progress our little people have made and know their kindergarten teachers will feel so blessed to have them in their class!
